gone
Power User
- Jan 23, 2020
- 1,630
- 2,044
Netsinah. I will respectfully disagree.
I believe all .... most .... many .... one (???) LEOs would investigate street racing complaints. Especially when there seems to be solid evidence like this case. Whether a charge is laid is at their (police) discretion and NOT the car owners.
Internet reviews .... waste of time IMHO.
OTOH. Asking advice from this community is something I would do.
Also I'd like to hear from a lawyer (maybe on this forum?) regarding potential success with a civil suit?
Well I am a lawyer and still work as one (almost 40 years now). I don't do criminal law but have some familiarity with "the system" due to conversations with others who practice nothing but criminal law. Unfortunately, I have too much experience defending traffic tickets issued to myself and my spouse. Our Edmonton traffic court is usually ++ busy, so much so that tickets that may be hard to prove or a hassle, get dropped. Police usually issue a ticket for something they witnessed or personally dealt with, rather than something a "civilian" tells them about. Perhaps not always, but that's what happens in general. For any civil suit to succeed, you have to prove not only the wrongdoing (and for example disprove the manager's claim he was investigating a "misfiring problem"), but also damages. It may be a challenge to prove damages in this instance and at the very least, you'd need an expert in automotive mechanics to establish C8 engine damage or some other damage "on a balance of probabilities". Such an expert doesn't come cheap, making the cost of pursuing this in a civil court, questionable on damages alone.
The OP is from Ontario so he's better off getting advice from an Ontario lawyer, since different jurisdictions have different laws and different approaches to traffic law enforcement.
Having said all that, I'll do the prudent C.Y.A. disclaimer that the above is not to be construed as "legal advice" but rather a sincere attempt to provide some helpful suggestions to another member of these Forums. Any lawyer should sit down and talk to someone and get 100% of the facts and documentation, before giving legal advice, plus I'm not an Ontario lawyer.