Arguments happen when nobody has proof and it's all opinion. An oil test tells everything there is to know about the oils life. There are web sites that show you everything there is to know about oil, it's quality new and it's quality old. I have a friend who is an oil guru. He has a vette and he always tests his oil. Not only that but he tests brands of oil. I don't bother testing the oil myself, but I do take his advice about the brand, type and viscosity etc.
Mobil1 has been a partner with GM for 50 years now. That doesn't mean that Mobil1 is the best oil. It may mean that GM wants to help Mobil1 sell oil.
Having said all that, an argument is useless without proof and I have none either and I couldn't be bothered to get any when I already have a guru to advise me. Yes, I'm also too lazy. lol